1888 N172 Old Judge Art Whitney with Dog - Card Intended as a Joke
Sold For: $705
Auction Year:2007 spring
Category:Pre-1900 Baseball Cards (1830-1899)
Rate This Item
Do you have an item like this that you're considering selling?
Do you want to make an offer on this exact item?
Graded VG 40 by SGC. 1888 N172 Goodwin Old Judge card featuring one of the most unusual and memorable images to ever appear on a baseball card of New York third baseman Art Whitney kneeling with dog. While the pose of this card alone makes it one of the most interesting images to appear in the Old Judge set, there is actually a story to this card which explains its significance. This photograph was apparently taken and included in the Old Judge set as a joke. Whitney was notorious for switching teams. Rarely has one player jumped from team to team as much as Art Whitney. Starting with the Worcester Nationals in 1880, he moved on to the Detroit Nationals in 1881, Providence in early 1882, back to Detroit late in 1882, on to Pittsburgh of the American Association from 1884 to 1886, before moving to the Pittsburgh Nationals in 1887, and then to New York in 1888 and 1889. Between 1890 and his last season in 1891, he added another three teams to his resume. Whitney is posed with a dog in this photograph as a study of two extremes, with the dog representing the most loyal of all animals, and Whitney representing the opposite. This card has four square corners and, as is often the case with Old Judges, the picture is a little light, though still very respectable. The blank reverse is very clean, with just the lightest hint of scrapbook removal in the upper left (barely detectable) and centering to the left largely responsible for the harsh grade assigned by SGC, otherwise Excellent. This is a very attractive example of one of the more interesting nineteenth-century baseball cards. Reserve $200. Estimate $400/$800. SOLD FOR $705.00