1907 A. C. Dietsche Detroit Tigers Postcard Ty Cobb Rookie - Extremely Rare Fielding Variation!

Sold For: $1,920

Auction Year: 2016 fall

Lot: 158

Item Year: 1907

Category: Prewar Baseball Cards (1900-1941)

Rate This Item

Graded FAIR 20 by SGC (submitted by REA). Extremely rare example of Ty Cobb's "fielding" pose variation card from the highly regarded A. C. Dietsche Detroit Tigers postcard set, issued in 1907. This issue was produced by the Dietsche Postcard Company of Detroit to commemorate the Tigers' participation in the 1907 World Series. Cobb is the only player with two poses in the Dietsche set, and for some reason the Cobb fielding pose is far rarer than the Cobb batting pose, to such an extraordinary degree that we can only assume the Cobb fielding pose was replaced with the batting pose early in the print run. We have not offered a single example of this card in the last 15 years. Of special note, this card is considered by many collectors to be Ty Cobb's true rookie card. A number of other issues can also lay claim to that important distinction. (We realize that the definition of what is a player's rookie card can sometimes be very controversial and can vary from collector to collector.) The fact that the Dietsche postcard set features a short biography of the player on the back makes this postcard even more "card-like" than many more traditional issues. The card features a crisp black-and-white image of Cobb fielding, with light touches of wear to the four corners, and a vertical crease in the background of the upper right portion of the card. The paper loss in the lower left corner accounts for the modest assigned grade despite an overall Excellent appearance. The Dietsche postcard of Ty Cobb represents an outstanding overlooked value compared to most other early Cobb cards, including those issued a couple of years later which are widely recognized by many collectors as Cobb's rookie cards. This is an outstanding example of this rare pose variation and what many collectors believe reasonably qualifies as Cobb's true rookie card. Reserve $400. Estimate $1,000++.


More items like this:

(Swipe images to see more)