Thank you for visiting our past auction result archives. If you have an item identical (or similar) to this auction lot, please call, write or contact us to discuss. We will be able to help you.

Lot # 352 (of 1673)   < Previous Lot | Next Lot >

1910 E93 Standard Caramel Complete Set on Two Uncut Sheets (2)

Starting Bid - $1,500.00 , Sold For - $7,637.50

Presented is an extremely rare and fascinating complete set of thirty E93 Standard Caramel cards, including eighteen Hall of Famers, on two uncut sheets. One sheet has twelve cards; the other has eighteen cards. Together they represent the entire set, and framed together, as they are presented, they actually have the appearance of a single complete sheet. It is almost unheard of for any uncut sheet of baseball cards to survive from the 1910 era. These E93 caramel cards are a very rare exception, and originate from a very small find of approximately five partial E93 sheets that surfaced in 2006. The fact that these sheets are blank-backed suggest that their survival relates somehow to the printer. What is certain is that only a few uncut sheets of E93s survive in complete or partial form, including the offered examples, and these few sheets represent an extremely unusual and extraordinary form for these cards, and a virtually unique opportunity for collectors. E93s are one of the most popular of all the 1910-era "E" candy card issues. The 30-card set was issued in 1910 by the Standard Caramel Co. of Lancaster, PA. The first uncut sheet, comprised of eighteen cards, includes the following Hall of Famers: Bender, Chance, Clarke, Evers, Jennings, Joss, Lajoie, Mathewson, Plank, and Waddell, plus eight additional stars. The second uncut sheet consists of twelve cards, featuring the following Hall of Famers: Brown, Cobb, Collins, Griffith, McGraw, Tinker, Wagner, and Young, plus four additional stars.


It is difficult to approach a sheet of this vintage and extreme rarity in the same manner as a single card, especially with reference to grading. The sheets display beautifully and overall have an Excellent appearance at a glance. Some individual cards would approach perfection if graded as separate cards, a few others have a light crease, while many edge cards have borders that are not full, and if they were separate cards would only be graded "Authentic." But they are not separate cards, they are part of two unique uncut sheets. The colors of these cards are brilliant; the rarity of these sheets is virtually unparalleled; and the display value is extraordinary. They are not perfect, but they will not sell for what perfect cards would sell for. In fact, historically, the market has sometimes valued sheets such as these at a significant discount to the individual cards on it. A complete high-grade set of E93s (admittedly the second finest set in existence, trailing only the #1 PSA registry "JimB'sE93" set) sold at auction in 2006 for approximately $300,000. The individual values of the cards on this sheet, in any condition, would be thousands of dollars. There is no consensus on the value of uncut sheets of E93s, in part because each of the few examples is different in terms of condition or number of cards. Common sense tells us that an uncut sheet should be worth at least the sum of its parts. These two uncut sheets of E93 Standard Caramel (representing a complete set), one of the most colorful and popular of all "E" card issues, form a rare and unique display piece, representing a potentially extraordinary value. Dimensions: 18-card sheet (9 x 8.5 inches) and 12-card sheet (9 x 5.25). Matted and framed to 19 x 24 inches. Reserve $1,500. Estimate $3,000/$5,000. SOLD FOR $7,637.50


(Click the smaller thumbnails to the left and right (if any) to cycle through each photo in the gallery of images for this lot.)